Beautiful Lagoon

A site about feeling beautiful

Mascara Comparisons September 10, 2011

Here you can find comparisons of different Mascaras to natural lashes. I will review each mascara I try (which is at minimum 1 every three months). I will rate them all but it is up to you to decide which is the best choice for you.

For each category:
1=worst
10= best
All Mascaras will be in Alphabetical order by Brand first then model.

As always you can Click to view the photos at full size.

Anastasia – Lash Lifting Mascara Before After
Color Black 8/10
Formula 7/10
Volumizing 6/10
Lengthening 8/10
Curling 1/10
Waterproof 0/10
Separation 8/10
Time it lasts 14 hours
Clumping a little
Flaking very little
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Bare Minerals – Flawless Definition Before After
Color Black 9/10
Formula 5/10
Volumizing 8/10
Lengthening 5/10
Curling 4/10
Waterproof 3/10
Separation 6/10
Time it lasts 8 hours
Clumping a little
Flaking some (tiny sized)
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Dior – Diorshow  Blackout Waterproof Mascara Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 8/10
Volumizing 8/10
Lengthening 6/10
Curling 5/10
Waterproof 9/10
Separation 6/10
Time it lasts 10 hours
Clumping a little
Flaking some
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Lancôme Hypnôse Doll Lash Mascara Review

Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 6/10
Volumizing 9/10
Lengthening 8/10
Curling 5/10
Waterproof 3/10
Separation 2/10
Time it lasts 9 hours
Clumping lots
Flaking some after 6 hours
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Lancôme Hypnôse Drama Mascara Review

Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 8/10
Volumizing 7/10
Lengthening 7/10
Curling 5/10
Waterproof 5/10
Separation 8/10
Time it lasts 14 hours
Clumping very little
Flaking none
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

LORAC multiplex 3D lashes Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 6/10
Volumizing 4/10
Lengthening 6/10
Curling 6/10
Waterproof 5/10
Separation 5/10
Time it lasts 14 hours
Clumping very little
Flaking none
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Make Up For Ever – Aqua Smoky Lash Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 7/10
Volumizing 5/10
Lengthening 6/10
Curling 5/10
Waterproof 10/10
Separation 8/10
Time it lasts 16 hours
Clumping very little
Flaking none
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Maybelline – The Falsies Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 4/10
Volumizing 8/10
Lengthening 1/10
Curling 0/10
Waterproof 5/10
Separation 5/10
Time it lasts 8 hours
Clumping some
Flaking lots
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Maybelline – Volume Express Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 4/10
Volumizing 3/10
Lengthening 6/10
Curling 1/10
Waterproof 2/10
Separation 3/10
Time it lasts 6 hours
Clumping some
Flaking some
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Rimmel Volume Accelerator Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 2/10
Volumizing 2/10
Lengthening 4/10
Curling 2/10
Waterproof 3/10
Separation 1/10
Time it lasts 8 hours
Clumping lots
Flaking some
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Tarte – Lights, Camera, splashes!

Before After
Color Black 10/10
Formula 6/10
Volumizing 4/10
Lengthening 4/10
Curling 6/10
Waterproof 10/10
Separation 9/10
Time it lasts 14 hours
Clumping none
Flaking none
Looking Up
Looking Down

.

Last update: 3/1/12

 

Speak up!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s